Best interest and expressed interest
Best interest and expressed interest
Your client tells you what he wants. Your investigation points somewhere else. This segment covers what you owe each of those, and what the practice standards require when they pull apart.
Objectives
- What best interest representation means, and what it does not
- How a client's stated wishes bear on your position
- The three things you owe a client when you disagree with them
The case
You will work one matter through this segment and into the conversation that follows it.
Last month you picked up a new case. Your clients are three siblings, Kevin, Derek and Gabby, removed from their mother. At the initial hearing you advocated for them to be placed with their father, and they were.
Earlier this week you went to see them at home. Derek, the middle sibling, told you their father forced Kevin to take some pills and then beat him. Gabby corroborated it.
When you spoke to Kevin during the same visit he did not mention it and said everything was fine at home. You noticed a black eye and some bruising on his face.
Kevin is 15. He wants to stay where he is, and he has asked you to tell the judge so.
Two things are true at once. Kevin has told you what he wants, clearly and in his own words. And what you have been told by his siblings, together with what you saw, points at a different answer.
What you were appointed to represent
In most jurisdictions, a guardian ad litem is appointed to represent the child's best interest.
Best interest is not a fixed standard you apply the same way every time. It is an individualized determination that varies case by case and rests on a thorough independent investigation.
Which means your position on Kevin is built from what you can corroborate: what Derek and Gabby said, what you observed, what the medical record shows, what the school knows, and what your investigation turns up between now and the next hearing.
Your recommendation is not constrained by what Kevin tells you he wants. Under express or stated interest representation, the client's wishes direct the lawyer's advocacy. That is not the role you hold here.
The two interests, side by side
Both are live in every case. Only one of them directs your advocacy.
Best interest
What you were appointed to advocate for. Determined case by case, built on independent investigation and corroborated facts. It sets your recommendation to the court.
Expressed interest
What your client tells you he wants. It does not direct your advocacy, and it always informs your representation. It is evidence, it shapes what you investigate, and it has to reach the court.
Treating a client's stated wish as something to work around is the common error. It is information you are obliged to take seriously, weigh, and carry forward, even where you end up recommending against it.
Where the conflict is deep enough, the court may appoint a separate express interest attorney for the child. That possibility does not move the duty off you in the meantime.
What you owe your client when you disagree
The role carries three obligations. They apply together, and the third one is not optional.
He understands why
Make sure the client understands why your recommendation is what it is. Not that you have one, but the reasoning behind it, in terms he can follow.
You close the gap where you can
Work out where your position and what he wants can be brought into line, and pursue that part. Rarely is the disagreement total.
His voice reaches the court
Where his wishes still differ from your recommendation, you are required to ensure they are expressed to the court anyway.
The aim is a client who can participate in his own case, not one who is managed through it.
Your position on Kevin
Two decisions. Commit to an answer, then read why. Your first response is the one that gets recorded.
ClickTap Next below to begin.
Now you have to tell him
0/2
You have taken a position. Kevin does not know it yet.
Knowing the rule and sitting across from a fifteen-year-old who trusted you enough to be placed where he is are different problems. The second one is a conversation, and conversations get practiced rather than read about.
This sample ends here. The conversation that follows it, in which Kevin responds to what you say and the three things you owe him are scored, is the guardian ad litem demo on the ChatTrain page.